The Class of 1913 Trophy is presented annually to the senior male and female student-athletes at Lafayette who have attained the greatest distinction both as an athlete and a scholar. This endowed award is voted on by the head coaches and athletic administrators.

Year	Student-Athlete
1940	James F. Bryant
1941	William John Collins
1942	Walter J. Zirinsky
1943	Richard H. Wright
1947	William R. Magee
1948	Frank J. Stanczak
1949	Martin Zippel
1950	Duane E. Warrick
1951	George E. Davidson
1952	Peter J. Carril
1953	William J. Shenko
1954	Leon A. Miller
1955	Thomas F. McGrail Jr.
1956	Ernest L. Peters
1957	Stuart A. Murray
1958	Albert H. Caesar, III
1959	Gordon S. Gibson
1960	Richard W. Haines
1961	Morris W. Boyer
1962	Harry L. Lundy, Jr.
1963	Ray A. Moyer
1964	Richard A. Thompson
1965	Douglas L. Dill
1966	Walter M. Manuel, Jr.
1967	William Vonroth, Jr.
1968	Paul Allen Link
1969	William N. Mandell
1970	Louis P. Soraruf, IV
1971	William A. Sprecher, Daniel C. Thomas, Jr.
1972	Joseph A. Mottola, Jr.
1973	Brian L. Canfield
1974	Paul E. Albright, Earl Brown, Denise McDougald
1975	Stanley Ciemniecki, Melissa J. Thoene
1976	Amelia A. Erickson, Steven Feldman
1977	Karin E. Klopping, Mark A. Ziegler
1978	Andrea S. Cohen, Daniel H. Price, IV
1979	Margaret L. Savage, James H. Medes, Jr.
1980	Cynthia A. Oaks, Robert P. Falconiero
1981	Leonard J. Artigliere, Deborah E. Yuhl
1982	Richard J.Mohr, Jr., Vicki D. O'Connor
1983	Cheryl L. Johnson, Kenneth D. Chavin, Joe Calhoun
1984	James L. Benjamin, Gwyn M. Groman
1985	James W. Dicker, Karen F. Kowalenko, Jeffrey D. Parker
1986	Gino Cara, Sharon Lukenda
1987	Charles E. Davis, Jayne M. O'Brien
1988	Mitch Bormack, Sue Shirley
1989	Otis B. Ellis, Renee S. Robbins
1990	Anthony Mazzei, Kelly Hawk
1991	Bruce Stankavage, Stephanie Pollock
1992	Tom Neale, Liz Bagley
1993	Eric Perry, Tinabeth Piña
1994	Heidi Caruso, Timo Papé
1995	Shannon Brennan, Jason McLaughlin
1996	Ignacio Fente, Angie Eifert, Stacy Durbin
1997	Alex Finio, Laura Lindquist, Matt Rutt
1998	Shelly Rush, David Biko
1999	Larissa Dodson, Renaldo Trancoso
2000	Joe Luke, Bob Osipower, Kellee Salber
2001	Craig Schroeder, Alison Fisher
2002	Stewart Kupfer, Lauren McHale
2003	Matt Tambellini, Ashley Wesmiller
2004	Matt Battiste, Meghan Ramsey
2005	Stephen Bono, Jenny Moerschbacher
2006	Mike Tortora, Jenna Bratz
2007	Brad Maurer, Lori Cooper
2008	Jaryd Freedman, Katie Schultes